The Case of the Politically Incorrect Sign

Question # 00645424
Subject: Law
Due on: 03/23/2023
Posted On: 03/23/2023 06:18 AM
Tutorials: 1
Rating:
4.9/5
Question Dot Image

California College San Diego Case of The Politically Incorrect Sign Discussion Questions

Need help with my Business Law question - I’m studying for my class.

You’re on the Jury : The Case of the Politically Incorrect Sign

Disturbed by the number and variety of signs that individuals were putting up within its borders, a City passed an ordinance prohibiting all signs on private property except in commercial areas for advertising. Sam, a homeowner, pasted a sign on the front door of his house containing an American flag with these words underneath the flag: “Down with the Mayor and the City Council – Our rights are being violated”. He then went door to door in his neighborhood passing out copies of this sign and asking his neighbors to display it as well. Sam was arrested for violating the ordinance.

The Trial

During the trial, a witness for the City described how many signs had appeared in the past on homes and on lawns for commercial home businesses, ruining the appearance of the community. He explained that many other cities and towns had experienced the same problems and that the ordinance was reasonable and the only way to solve the problem. The restriction, he said, was content neutral as it was addressing a societal problem. Sam testified that the sign he had put up was a small one and that other City residents had raised flags on national holidays and put up signs showing their patriotism. None of these residents had been arrested.

The Arguments at Trial

The City’s attorney argued that a city had the authority to regulate signs within its borders to protect the appearance and value of properties. She further argued that the ordinance did not unduly restrict free speech as there were other ways for residents to express their views: radio, television, and the newspapers. Sam’s attorney argued that the regulation violated the freedom of speech provisions of the federal constitution, was too broad, too vague, and was unreasonable. He argued that the City could have limited the ordinance by restricting signs over a certain size and in certain locations. He further argued that it was unreasonable to restrict the expression of opinions except for the use of the media.

Discussion Questions to be Answered

  1. Who has the stronger arguments, the City or Sam? Why?
  2. What are the laws here that are being applied and is their application proper?
  3. If you were the on the jury hearing this case, for whom would you decide? Why?
Dot Image
Getsolution Posted By :
Questions: 14694 Tutorials: 14694
Tutorials for this Question

The Case of the Politically Incorrect Sign

Tutorial # 00644308
Posted On: 03/23/2023 06:19 AM
Feedback Score: Not rated yet!
Purchased By: 2
Getsolution
Posted By:
Questions:
14694
Tutorials:
14694
Report this Tutorial as Inappropriate
Tutorial Preview
The solution of The Case of the Politically Incorrect Sign...
Attachments
The_Case_of_the_Politically_Incorrect_Sign.ZIP (18.96 KB)

Great! We have found the solution of this question!

Related Questions
Module 2 Assignment 2 - The Scott Peterson Case
Module 2: Module 2 - M2 Assignment 2 Assignment 2: The Scott Peterson Case  You are required to research the Scott Peterson case and prepare a summary report of the events that led to his a …
Recent News Event in Which Perceptions Reduced Civil Discourse
Recent News Event in Which Perceptions Reduced Civil Discourse Civility and Social Justice Discussion Chapter 2-4 in your text discusses situations in which civility and social justice were directl …
Reflections on the tensions between the Executive
Reflections on the tensions between the Executive and Congressional Budget Processes. Reflections on the tensions between the Executive and Congressional Budget Processes As one Congressional Re …
Ashford CRJ303 Correctional Functions and Goals
CRJ303 Ashford University Correctional Functions and Goals Correctional Functions and Goals [WLOs: 1, 2] [CLOs: 1, 2] Prior to beginning work on this discussion, r …
Ashford CRJ303 Constitutional Rights & Administrative Goals
CRJ303 Ashford Constitutional Rights & Administrative Goals Paper prior to beginning work on this assignment, please review the assigned material in your Stojkovic and Lovell (2019) textbook. A …
Ashford CRJ303 Constitutional Rights & Administrative Goals
CRJ303 Ashford University Constitutional Rights & Administrative Goals Paper Constitutional Rights and Administrative Goals [WLOs: 1, 2, 3] [CLOs: 2, 4] Prior to beginning work on this as …
Ashford CRJ303 Federal Bureau of Prisons Discussion
CRJ303 Ashford University Federal Bureau of Prisons Discussion Paper Twitter Forum: Working for the Federal Bureau of Prisons [WLOs: 1, 2, 3] [CLOs: 1, 2] Prior to …
Ashford CRJ303 Week 2 Issues & Constitutional Rights in Corrections
CRJ303 Ashford Week 2 Issues & Constitutional Rights in Corrections Paper Prior to beginning work on this assignment, read Chapters 1 and 2 from your textbook, watch the video Overcrowded: …
Ashford CRJ303 Issues and Constitutional Rights in Corrections
CRJ303 Ashford Issues and Constitutional Rights in Corrections Paper Issues and Constitutional Rights in Corrections [WLOs: 1, 2, 4] [CLOs: 1, 2, 3, 4] Prior to beginning work on this assignm …
In Preparing for Disasters FEMA Recommends Taking a Whole
ACCC ?in Preparing for Disasters FEMA Recommends Taking a Whole Community Approach In preparing for disasters, FEMA recommends taking a whole community approach (2011). Take a look at the resource …
Recent Questions
Discussion - Conditioned reinforcement, Identify a behavior that a chaining
Discussion questions 1. Review the presentation titled "Conditioned reinforcement" in chapter 10. 2. Identify a behavior that a chaining procedure would be appropriate to use to teach …
Discussion Chapter 20 - Identify the various terms members
Chapter twenty discussion board 54 Chapter twenty discussion board item: Identify the various terms members of the Ecstasy-using community use to describe their experiences with the drug (&lsquo …
PSYC465 - Describe a recent conflict or negative situation
PSYC 465 MARRIAGE Read Chapters 5, 6, and Appendix A from The DNA of Relationships for Couples. Answer the two questions (Smalley and Paul, 2006, Appendix A) posed in Appendix A (the questions a …
Abanormal Week 11 - Why is marijuana the most frequently
Abanormal week 11 For the discussion this week, consider and address the following questions (all questions need to be answered): Why is marijuana the most frequently used illegal drug in the U. …
Week 4 Assignment - Behavioral Neuroscience Research Paper
Psychology Question Week 4 Assignment - Final BN Research Paper Behavioral Neuroscience Research Paper"Biologically Based Psychological Disorders"For your Behavioral Neuroscience …
Develop your own family genogram, The Genogram
Genogram Project -  Develop your own family genogram. The Genogram must be representative of at least 3 generations, including yourself i.e. Your grandparents, your parents, You; Your parents …
Maria Sanchez is a 60-year-old Latina woman who has concerns
Scenario: Maria Sanchez is a 60-year-old Latina woman who has concerns about her neighbor Lynn, a 21-year-old White woman. Lynn appears to have “issues” and is disturbing the neighbors at …
Chapter 4 - Describe what you find to be important in order for a person
After reading Brooks chapter 4, answer the following aswer the question After reading Brooks chapter 4, answer the following: Describe, in your own words, what you find to be important in ord …
Demonstrate your understanding of sociology and culture by explaining
Chapter twenty-two NOTE: Points will be deducted for the inclusion of outside references.  The resources you need to complete assignments are to be found in the assigned course readings.   …
PSY310 - A key concept in operant conditioning
Punishment A key concept in operant conditioning is to examine how the consequences of a behavior contribute to the likelihood of the behavior occurring again.  Is there a behavior of yours (o …