PHIL2306 Introduction to Ethics
Discussion Question 1
Moral Principles
Do you believe that moral principles are absolute or should they allow for exceptions? Consider the examples of lying, killing, and stealing. Is it always wrong to lie, kill, and steal, or are there circumstances when those actions might be ethically permissible (put aside the legal implications of those actions for this question). If so, can you think of circumstances in which those actions might be ethically permissible?
PHIL2306 Introduction to Ethics
Discussion Question 2
Ethical Topics
Discussion Question #2: Give an example of an ethical topic or two that have piqued your interest in the past and explain why (e.g., abortion, physician-assisted suicide, income inequality, capital punishment, genetic engineering, etc.). One of these topics may be the subject of your Critical Analysis Paper (CAP) later on.
PHIL2306 Introduction to Ethics
Discussion Question 3
Material Wealth
Philosophy's first martyr, Socrates, warned his fellow Athenians in the Apology that the sole pursuit of material wealth corrupts the kind of person that we are. Explain whether you agree with this statement or not, especially in light of the “Meaning of Life” Power Point. In what way can wealth be corrupting? Does it depend on the person or circumstance?
PHIL2306 Introduction to Ethics
Discussion Question 4
Ethics of Technology
After watching the PBS program, 22nd Century, consider the advantages and disadvantages of the World-Wide Mind (WWM). Can you think of beneficial ways in which the WWM can be put to good use? Are there any concerns that you might have with it?
PHIL2306 Introduction to Ethics
Discussion Question 5
Poverty and Animal Rights
Do you find any of Peter Singer’s arguments on poverty (i.e., that we have an ethical obligation to assist those less fortunate than us) or his arguments on animal rights (that we have an ethical duty to treat nonhuman animals ethically) to be persuasive? Why or why not? Explain your reasoning.
PHIL2306 Introduction to Ethics
Discussion Question 6
Car Crash Testing
Are you persuaded by the utilitarian justification of cadaver use in car crash testings (that the data from those tests go on to save more lives in the future with improved safety features)? Why or why not? Assume that the participants gave prior informed consent for their bodies to be used in those tests. Explain your reasoning.
PHIL2306 Introduction to Ethics
Discussion Question 7
Three Types of Friendships
Aristotle distinguished among three types of friendships (pleasure, utility, and character). Do you
agree with his characterizations (see below) or not? Can you think of examples or criticisms of any of these types?
--Pleasure: Since the good that is desired on both sides is pleasure and enjoyment, relationships of this sort tend to
fade and break off when what had given pleasure ceases to do so; friendship of young people often tend to be of this
kind.
-- Utility: This is largely based on the usefulness that is served by being nice to one another, as is in the workplace;
there is little to sustain the relationship when the mutual utility ceases.
-- Character: We wish well to our friends for their own sake; both parties
PHIL2306 Introduction to Ethics
Discussion Question 8
Friendships
Presuming that friends will give one another the “benefit of the doubt” and allow for all sorts of
things out of friendship, when does it become necessary to break off a friendship? Is a direct confrontation better for breaking off such a relationship, or is it better to use some indirect course, such as neglect or atrophy, until the person ceases to be in contact?
PHIL2306 Introduction to Ethics
Exam #1
Question 1
Ethics is the branch of philosophy that studies ___.
the nature of right and wrong, good and bad
principles of correct reasoning
the nature and structure of reality
the nature of beauty
how humans acquire knowledge
Question 2
The “ideal moral judgment” ought to include all of the following, except ___.
conceptual clarity
coolness
rationality
impartiality
economic implications
Question 3
Which of the following is false of normative statements?
Normative statements are indistinguishable from factual statements.
A normative statement expresses a value judgment of some kind.
The correctness of a normative statement is determined by reference to a norm or standard.
An example of such a statement would be: “Affluent nations have a moral duty to assist impoverished nations.”
All of them are true.
Question 4
What are some of the benefits of studying ethics?
Ethics helps us to participate intelligently in today’s ethical debates.
Various professions have professional codes of conduct to which we may be subjected.
We might find ourselves called before an ethics or disciplinary board to give an account of our actions.
All of the above.
None of the above.
Question 5
With which of the following statements about moral expertise would the philosopher C. D. Broad agree?
It is not part of the professional business of moral philosophers to tell people what they ought or ought not to do.
Moral philosophers have no special information not available to the general public about what is right and what is wrong.
They do not have a calling to undertake those hortatory functions which are so adequately performed by clergymen, politicians, and leader-writers.
All of the above.
None of the above.
Question 6
Why does Peter Singer believe that ethicists have moral expertise (and be considered soft experts)?
His general training as a philosopher should make him more than ordinarily competent in argument and in the detection of invalid inferences, such as logical fallacies.
His specific experience in moral philosophy gives him an understanding of moral concepts, such as ethical theories, and of the logic of moral argumentation.
The moral philosopher can, if he wants, think full-time about moral issues, while most other people have some occupation to pursue which interferes with such reflection.
All of the above.
A and C only.
Question 7
According to Peter Singer, what is ethics not about?
It should not only be about a set of prohibitions particularly concerned with sex. There are other important ethical issues to discuss.
It is not an ideal system that is noble in theory but no good in practice.
It is not something intelligible only in the context of religion. It is possible to think critically and responsibly about ethical issues independently of religious consideration.
It is not relative or subjective.
All of the above.
Question 8
Central to morality are moral principles which have five traits. Which of the following is NOT one of those five?
Practicability
Prescriptivity
Economics
Overridingness
Universalizability
Question 9
The word “moral” comes from the Latin meaning ____ and the Greek meaning ____--respectively. Each derives their meaning from the idea of custom.
violation; punishment
mores; ethos
reward; altruism
prison; freedom
blameworthy; guilt
Question 10
Generally there are four domains that evaluate rules of right conduct. Which of the following is NOT one of those four?
Motive
Action
Depravity
Character
Consequences
PHIL2306 Introduction to Ethics
Exam #2
Question 1
PBS 22nd Century: Who is the author of Brave New World?
Alduous Huxley
James Hughes
Ramez Naam
Charles Darwin
Peter Singer
Question 2
PBS 22nd Century: Orlanda Bell is an astral projection: half ___, half ____.
horse; man
human; machine
zebra; lion
amoeba; paramecium
hardware; software
Question 3
PBS 22nd Century: Erick Ramsey is locked in—which means that he is ____.
dead
kicked out of his parents’ house forever
always getting himself locked in various rooms
an expert locksmith
totally aware of his surroundings, but not able to communicate with the outside world
Question 4
PBS 22nd Century: Erick’s professional ambition is to become a ___.
lawyer
doctor
mathematician
Disney artist
astronomer
Question 5
According to Ramez Naam, the term ___ (as used in science fiction) refers to a person who has technology implanted inside his body; one who is part human and part machine.
zombie
alien
cyborg
demon
robot
Question 6
PBS 22nd Century: According to Ramez Naam, as long as humanity has existed we have always looked for ways to ___.
make ourselves smarter
live longer
You Answered
improve who we are and our environment
Correct Answer
All of the above.
A and C only.
Question 7
PBS 22nd Century: Michael Chorost (who considered himself an early cyborg) received a ___.
cochlear implant
liver transplant
heart transplant
leg amputation
vascetomy
Question 8
PBS 22nd Century: Bill McKibben, a transhumanist critic, mentions which of the following as making us human?
Our commitment to one another.
Love of art, music, and literature.
Our interest in the spiritual and philosophical.
Our ability to fall in love.
All of the above.
Question 9
According to the Harvard psychologist, Howard Gardner, once we “[h]ave reached our adult years, and attained a certain level of competence in our chosen pursuits, ___.”
we can safely assume that life’s lessons will automatically dawn upon us with no further reflection
we should strive to move up, to go up, to achieve, to conquer
we should question what the meaning of life is
we cannot assume that lessons from experience will automatically dawn on us
we should not be bogged down by a mid-life crisis
Question 10
As described by Albert Camus, the main character in the Myth of Sisyphus is ___.
hospitalized for contracting syphilis
praised by the gods for his unadulterated devotion to them
condemned by the gods to roll a boulder up and down a hill
paid a lot of money for working as a forklift driver
delivering a UPS parcel from one place to another for eternity
PHIL2306 Introduction to Ethics
Exam #3
Question 1
In the Colbert Report episode where Peter Singer discussed his views on poverty, what book was featured in that episode?
The Life You Can Save
Ethics in the Real World
Animal Liberation
Practical Ethics
The Ethics of What We Eat
Question 2
Which of the following statements is/are true of John Stuart Mill?
He was born in England.
He was a child prodigy.
He had a mental breakdown in his early 20's.
All of the above.
A and C only.
Question 3
Utilitarianism is especially applicable to ___ decision making, which is what the classical utilitarians originally had in mind.
statutory (pertaining to laws)
religious
social or governmental policies
All of the above.
A and C only.
Question 4
The classical utilitarians were social reformers who lived during the time of the ____ and saw an immense amount of suffering on the part of large numbers of people.
Great Depression
Roaring Twenties
Industrial Revolution
Vietnam War
Civil War
Question 5
In the Colbert Report episode where Peter Singer discussed his views on poverty, which of the following hypothetical scenario did he bring up to advance his argument?
If you ran out of gas on a highway, would you siphon gas from a stranded motorist?
If you were offered two equally-paid jobs in two different cities, which one would you take?
If you’re walking past a pond and see a child drowning, would you jump in and try to save the child?
If money were not a problem, would you still want to work?
If you were the only person on the planet, would you still care about ethics?
Question 6
A supererogatory act is one that ___.
goes above and beyond the call of duty
would be good to do but not wrong not to do
only a Superman-type of person can perform
is publicly acknowledged by society
is condemned by virtually all society
Question 7
Before presenting his arguments regarding world poverty, what assumption does Singer make explicit?
That God exists and He cares for his children.
That sexual issues are the only ethical topics worthy of discussion.
That children are worth saving more than adults.
That evolution will inevitably lead to an X-Men type of species.
That suffering and death from lack of food, shelter, and medical care are bad.
Question 8
Which of the following are characteristics of extreme poverty?
inability to meet basic needs for survival
lack of safe drinking water and sanitation
inability to secure adequate medical care
All of the above.
A and C only.
Question 9
In the Colbert Report episode where Peter Singer discussed his views on animal rights, what book was featured in that episode?
The Way We Eat: Why Our Food Choices Matter
Practical Ethics
Animal Liberation
Ethics in the Real World
The Life You Can Save
Question 10
A speciesist, as defined by Peter Singer, is a person who ___.
tries to save every species on the planet
attempts to annihilate every species on the planet
cares more about the suffering of members of his own species than those of another species
is knowledgeable about biology
believes in the technological superiority of his species over others